Join us.

We’re working to create a just society and preserve a healthy environment for future generations. Donate today to help.

Donate

Legal Scholars to Senate: Here Are the 12 Worst Provisions of the Permitting Bill that Should Not Become Law

Climate Justice Public Protections Responsive Government Air Climate Defending Safeguards Energy Environmental Justice Natural Resources

Editor’s note: Since initial distribution on November 13, more scholars have signed on to the letter outlined in this post. You can check for updated versions here.

Following the U.S. Senate’s November 9 vote to move forward with debate on the so-called Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 (BAAJA, S. 5653 / H.R. 2347), more than 90 legal scholars from across the country signed a letter we drafted urging senators to strip 12 particularly harmful provisions from the permitting bill during the amendment process. If those provisions remain when debate concludes, the scholars urged senators to vote “no” on final passage.

At the outset, the scholars make clear that they support building clean energy and transmission quickly. But they warn that BAAJA would “inflict permanent, sweeping damage on the nation’s core environmental laws (and on the people and environment they are designed to protect), and the public debate over it has been dangerously shallow.”

The letter continues:

Whatever modest emissions reductions its transmission reforms may deliver cannot justify the rollback that comes with them. And the threat posed by this lame-duck initiative provides a template and momentum for rollbacks far beyond environmental protections — potentially undercutting enforcement of public health protections, civil rights, public education, consumer finance, and more.

Not an Effective Climate or Emissions Reduction Bill

The letter also takes on the claim, advanced by some of BAAJA’s proponents, that the bill is a climate win:

BAAJA is sold as a climate compromise. It is nothing of the kind. It trades near-term, concrete, and often irreversible harms, borne first by low-income, Tribal, and frontline communities, for climate benefits that are distant, modest, and uncertain.

To be direct: this bill would make it easier to destroy wetlands that shield low-income Gulf Coast communities from storm surge, and harder for anyone to stop it in court. In exchange, decades from now, those same communities might be spared somewhat worse flooding from emissions we are only partially reducing.

The climate case does not rescue the bill. In the worst case of the most favorable modeling, the bill leaves emissions roughly where they are today. That modeling assumes liquefied natural gas (LNG) exports 8 to 15 percent higher without counting their emissions, and it projects pipeline construction up to 34 percent above recent levels. It makes no attempt to price in the gutting of the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), the Clean Water Act, and the Endangered Species Act, or the gas-powered data centers that the bill’s forever permits would protect, creating path-dependency that extends the period during which fossil fuel use will generate harmful greenhouse gas emissions. The climate benefits are backloaded and contingent. The harms would begin the day the bill is signed.

BAAJA’s 12 Most Harmful Provisions

The letter identifies the 12 provisions that would do the most damage and urges senators to remove each of them. For every provision, an appendix to the letter explains what it does, who it harms, and why it matters:

  1. “Forever Permits” (Section 1401)
  2. A Taxpayer-Funded Windfall for Developers (Section 1402)
  3. No Remedy for a Proven Violation (Section 1110)
  4. Closing the Courthouse Doors (Section 1110)
  5. Exempting Gas Pipelines from Review (NEPA Section 3)
  6. Letting Developers Define the Question and Freezing the Science
  7. Review by Exception: Categorical Exclusions and State Substitution
  8. Hobbling State and Tribal Water Quality Authority (Clean Water Act Section 401)
  9. Easier Wetland Destruction (Clean Water Act Sections 402 and 404)
  10. Weakening the Endangered Species Act
  11. A Fast Lane for Gas-Powered Data Centers
  12. Sidelining Tribal Nations and Sacred Places (National Historic Preservation Act)

These 12 provisions are not the only troubling parts of BAAJA. For more on the bill and the harm it would do to people, communities, and the environment, see our previous posts here and here.

A Problematic Process

The bill’s substance is troubling enough, but the process that has carried it through the Senate so far is just as concerning. As the letter explains:

A bill that would permanently restructure judicial review, Tribal consultation, and state water quality authority demands a record. This one has none: no hearing, no markup, no committee report. It rides on H.R. 2347, an unrelated tax bill. The 575 federally recognized Tribal Nations and the public had roughly two days to absorb a 494-page substitute before the November 9 cloture vote. Courts, not Congress, will be left to decide what it means. A new Congress takes office on January 3, 2027. Waiting a few weeks costs little; enacting this text could cost a decade.

A Chance to Speak Up

BAAJA could return to the Senate floor as early as Monday, November 16, with further action possible on Tuesday, November 17. If you would like to weigh in on the bill, please contact your senators today, and feel free to point them to the scholars’ letter.

Climate Justice Public Protections Responsive Government Air Climate Defending Safeguards Energy Environmental Justice Natural Resources

Subscribe to CPRBlog Digests

Subscribe to CPRBlog Digests to get more posts like this one delivered to your inbox.

Subscribe